Religious doctrines that boost fertility outcompete rival religious groups demographically.
Evidence
It is no accident that religious conservative attitudes on womenâs rights, contraception, abortion, and sexual orientation are conducive to maintaining high fertility levels. The reproductive advantage of prosocial religions is therefore another key factor that explains the latterâs cultural survival and expansion. Culturally transmitted prosocial religious beliefs and practices appear not only to have effects on cooperation and trust, but they also have direct Darwinian fitness consequences that contribute to the demographic growth and stability of large cooperative groups. Of course, not all religions encourage reproductive success (consider the Shakers, who banned sexual intercourse). However, I hope it is clear by now that in the logic of cultural evolution, there is no reason to expect that all religious groups reproduce at high levels. The logic is simply that those religious groups with beliefs and practices that promote population growth (be it by conversions, or higher fertility rates, or both), all else being equal, would outcompete their rivalsâincluding religious rivals like the Shakers and the self-castrating Skoptsyâand take a larger share of the religious market, and ultimately the worldâs population. â Norenzayan, Ara, Big gods - how religion transformedâŠ, 499
Categorization
- XREF: Connects to the readerâs framework: conservative reproductive doctrine as a cultural survival mechanism complementing the Big God moral-enforcement mechanism; also relevant to Baumardâs partner-choice lens on costly signals.
- ADDENDUM: Relates to âOn Sacrificeâ â the Shakers and Skoptsy as extreme self-limiting religious groups parallel sacrificial dynamics of giving up reproductive capacity for devotional identity.