Medieval scholars fabricated that Muhammadâs sexual boast was in the Qurâan
Evidence
This is not a particularly authoritative translation, and may well be only a case of giving Muhammad all the attributes of a popular hero and pleasing his simpler followers; but it was cited by all the best-informed and most serious mediaeval writers, sometimes in a vaguer form which gives it a nastier sound, for example, ânon erubuit ut diceret datum suis renibus a Deo, xu viros in coitu potentissimus fortitudine libidinis adaequareâ. It soon came to be believed that this âboastâ was in the Qurâan: âipse enim gloriatur in lege sua quod data sit sibi potestas in lumbis âŠâ said Humbert, completing the quotation in the usual form. â Norman Daniel, Islam and the West, 556
Categorization
- XREF: Echoes the vaultâs claim that âIslamâ as constitutive outside is built on textual fabrication and misattribution â here a boast falsely placed in the Qurâan by serious medieval writers.
- QUESTION: Worth chasing: how does the attribution drift â a hadith-like anecdote becomes âbelieved to be in the Qurâanâ â resemble modern selective quotation of Islamic sources by polemicists?