Concept formation is an ontological claim about what matters, not mere definition.
Evidence
Sartori developed a semantic and deļ¬nitional approach to concepts. In contrast, my approach is ontological, realist, and causal. The core attributes of a concept constitute a theory of the ontology of the phenomenon under consideration. Concepts are about ontology. To develop a concept is more than providing a deļ¬nition: it is deciding what is important about an entity. The arguments about why attribute X is important form part of the ontological theory of the object. ā Gary Goertz, Social Science Concepts, 191
Categorization
- DEFINE: Draws the line between Sartoriās semantic-definitional approach to concepts and Goertzās ontological, realist, causal one ā a framework distinction worth keeping straight when reading any concept-formation literature.
- XREF: Connects to earlier edited-volume material on how concept attributes encode causal theories, and to any work arguing that classification is never neutral (e.g. the AI-training-as-infrastructure claims).