Achimeir blamed rabbinic theology, not Rome, for the Jewish empire’s fall

Evidence

In a rapture of melodrama, the author puts the Goth’s fall to the Arabs on a par with history’s great disasters. Yet even if the sack of Saragossa is ordained by the “judgment of God” (iudicio Dei), the causes for the catastrophe seem not to be divine disfavor but rather the evil machinations of the Arab invaders and of a few bad apples among the Goths: not only Rodrigo but also Oppa, son of the evil king Egica. “After forcing his way to Toledo, the royal city, [Mûsâ] imposed on the adjacent regions an evil and fraudulent peace. He decapitated on a scaffold those noble lords who had remained, arresting them in their flight from Toledo with the help of Oppa, King Egica’s son. With Oppa’s support, he killed them all with the sword.” The intrigues of men like Oppa, along with the cowardice of others (such as Sindered, bishop of Toledo, who fled to Rome44), allow the Saracens to establish their “savage reign” (regnum efferum). — John V. Tolan, Saracens, 477 (#complicates, via linked claim)

Categorization

• XREF: connects to: Medieval Christian scholars’ blame of Jews matched contemporary anti-Semitism, not history — Norman Daniel, Islam and the West, 2046; The Christian chronicler blamed Arab victory on Gothic treason and cowardice, not divine disfavor — John V. Tolan, Saracens, 477

Broader Connections

• The Christian chronicler blamed Arab victory on Gothic treason and cowardice, not divine disfavor #complicates (0.74) — John V. Tolan, Saracens, 477