Digital Mind 🧠

🪵 The Threshold
Home

❯

01-Claims

❯

Supernatural watchers and rituals jointly forged large-scale moral communities

Supernatural watchers and rituals jointly forged large-scale moral communities

Properties1
tagsja-picks, category/definitional-content

Sep 20, 20261 min read

Supernatural watchers and rituals jointly forged large-scale moral communities

Related

  • Supernatural beliefs that mildly violate intuitions spread better than others (similarity 0.82)
  • Majority and prestigious endorsement boosts spread of supernatural beliefs (similarity 0.82)
  • Belief in supernatural watchers depends on both intuitive cognition and cultural transmission (similarity 0.81)
  • Supernatural monitoring, not moral emotions alone, scaled prosociality to mass societies (similarity 0.81)
  • Group expansion drives religion toward moral, demanding, interventionist gods (similarity 0.81)
  • As groups grow, moral enforcement and religion become intertwined. (similarity 0.80)
  • Supernatural monitoring drove human groups to scale from small bands to vast societies (similarity 0.80)
  • Religious belief stems from both intuitive cognition and cultural transmission mechanisms. (similarity 0.79)
  • Prosocial religious cohesion inherently requires excluding nonbelievers from trust (similarity 0.79)
  • Moral intuitions bind strangers into sacred communities that outcompete rivals (similarity 0.79)
  • The Church’s moral language structured who counted as monstrous others (similarity 0.79)
  • Big Gods and costly rituals coevolved to enhance cooperation and outcompete rivals (similarity 0.78)
  • Religious groups outsourced monitoring to gods and outcompeted rivals (similarity 0.78)

✉️
  • Supernatural watchers and rituals jointly forged large-scale moral communities
  • Related

Backlinks

  • Agricultural societies favor doctrinal rituals and moralistic Big Gods
  • Big Gods and costly rituals coevolved to enhance cooperation and outcompete rivals
  • Big Gods historically bound anonymous strangers together where courts and police were absent
  • Early Chinese civilization may have relied on supernatural monitoring despite the stereotype
  • Group expansion drives religion toward moral, demanding, interventionist gods
  • Humans need legends to bear responsibility for un-chosen deeds
  • Majority and prestigious endorsement boosts spread of supernatural beliefs
  • Moralizing supernatural agents help sustain cooperation at scales beyond natural limits
  • Resource conflict, large groups, and watchful gods co-occur across world societies.
  • Supernatural agents' minimal counterintuitiveness explains their cultural advantage
  • Supernatural beliefs that mildly violate intuitions spread better than others
  • Supernatural monitoring needs neither monotheism nor creator status
  • The Church's moral language structured who counted as monstrous others