Progun lawmakers invoked mourning to silence gun-policy debate after Newtown

Evidence

After the Newtown shooting, several progun lawmakers accused their critics of exploitation. The aide to Congressman Jim Jordan proclaimed that it was ā€œtime to mourn, not to debate policyā€ (Shear, 2012). Iowa Congressman Steve King joined in the denunciation, ā€œpolitical opportunists didn’t wait 24 hours before they decided they were going to go after some kind of a gun banā€ (Shear, 2012). His aide, Brittany Lesser, echoed the talk taboo ā€œamidst the funerals of these brave young children and adultsā€ (Shear, 2012). King also trivialized the effect of real guns by comparing them to childhood cap guns: ā€œWe all had our cap pistols when I was growing up, and that didn’t seem to cause mass murders in the street.ā€ — Albert Bandura, Moral Disengagement, 1244

Categorization

  • XREF: Connects to tactical topic-avoidance in moral disengagement literature and to how power deflects hard questions by invoking grief.
  • SEED: Angle: the ā€˜time to mourn, not to debate’ move as a recurring rhetorical shield across policy crises — Newtown, school shootings generally, and disasters where regulators are blamed for politicizing.