Peter the Venerable depicted Muhammad as a fraud taught Jewish and heretical fables

Evidence

Peter describes Muhammad as a poor, vile, unlettered Arab who achieved wealth and power through bloodshed, thievery, and intrigue. Finally realizing that a feigned religious vocation would serve his ambitions, he claimed that he was a prophet and usurped the authority of king. Then, at the bidding of Satan, a heretical Nestorian monk named Sergius came and joined Muhammad: together, along with several Jews, they forged a new heretical doctrine. “Muhammad, schooled in this way by the ïŹnest teachers—Jews and heretics—composed his Koran. He wove together, in his barbarous fashion, nefarious scripture from the fables of the Jews and the ditties of the heretics.” — John V. Tolan, Saracens, 842

Categorization

  • ADDENDUM: Supplies a concrete medieval origin for the modern trope of Islam as a derivative corruption stitched from Jewish and Christian error, relevant to the vault claims mapped via Anidjar/Aziz/Razack.
  • QUESTION: Trace whether the specific ‘Sergius the Nestorian monk as Muhammad’s secret teacher’ motif survives into modern Islamophobic discourse.