Open violence destroyed segregationist groups while respectable homeowner politics thrived

Evidence

Although Wallace tried to portray himself and his organization as respectable, the damage to the image of both had already been done. In its early years, the WECC had succeeded where the Columbians and Klan had failed, largely because it managed to disguise the rabidity of racial violence with the respectability of community politics. Rather than project an air of lawlessness and violence, WECC members presented themselves as hard-working, honest homeowners, concerned about their families, their homes, their neighborhoods and their city. Their motivation was not racism, they insisted, but their rights. But as soon as the organization resorted to outright violence, it ceded all claims to respectability and steadily lost its appeal. Within a few years, Joe Wallace had no credibility and no following. But other segregationist groups in Atlanta looked to the WECC example. They realized that success lay in respectability and a “reasonable” appeal to middle-class values, while violence and open bigotry would only lead to failure. — Kevin M. Kruse, White Flight, 138

Categorization

  • XREF: This is the core mechanism of the reader’s whole thesis: segregationist ideology forced into retreat from overt violence and reinvented as respectable homeowner-rights politics, which connects to the book’s larger arc about color-blind suburban conservatism. — connects to: Elite public silence helped segregationist defiance escalate in Charlotte. — Matthew D. Lassiter, The Suburban Origins of “Color-Blind”…, 57; Desegregation pressure forced segregationists to reinvent themselves as respectable homeowners — Kevin M. Kruse, White Flight: Atlanta and the Making of…, 106; Respectable segregationism paired capitalism rhetoric with veiled mob violence — Kevin M. Kruse, White Flight: Atlanta and the Making of…, 132 (+5 more)
  • DEFINE: Shows a key historical mechanism: WECC’s success depended on dressing racial violence in the language of homeowner “rights,” a framing that would later morph into color-blind suburbia.

Broader Connections