National love derives from assimilating the nation to unchosen natural ties
Evidence
Something of the nature of this political love can be deciphered from the ways in which languages describe its object: either in the vocabulary of kinship (motherland, Vaterland, patria) or that of home (heimat or tanah air [earth and water, the phrase for the Indonesiansâ native archipelago]). Both idioms denote something to which one is naturally tied. As we have seen earlier, in everything ânaturalâ there is always something unchosen. In this way, nation-ness is assimilated to skin-colour, gender, parentage and birth-era â all those things one can not help. And in these ânatural tiesâ one senses what one might call âthe beauty of gemeinschaftâ. To put it another way, precisely because such ties are not chosen, they have about them a halo of disinterestedness. â Benedict Anderson, Imagined Communities, 546
Categorization
- DEFINE: Explains how âthe beauty of gemeinschaftâ and the âhalo of disinterestednessâ name the mechanism by which national attachments feel unchosen and thus pure.
- XREF: The âeverything natural is unchosenâ move and disinterestedness echo the scaffolding Anderson builds toward racismâs naturalizing logic later in the chapter; also connects to the Halbwachs-style collective identity literature. â connects to: Nationality persists as attachment even after citizenship and state loyalty are severed; Societal ills stem partly from separation from reciprocal land love â Robin Wall Kimmerer, Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom,âŠ, 441