Moynihanâs report blamed Black mothers while ignoring state-imposed disadvantages and New Deal exclusion.
Evidence
Daniel Patrick Moynihanâs 1965 report The Negro Family: The Case for National Action furthered the theory that Black mothers were responsible for the disintegration of the Black family and the consequent failure of Black people to succeed in America. But hundreds of years of state-imposed hardship and unequal treatment made such success nearly impossible for most Black people: in addition to monumental losses inflicted by enslavement, Black families had been severely disadvantaged by racist housing policies, employment discrimination, inferior schools, exclusionary banking practices, and unjust law enforcement. They were also deliberately prevented from benefiting from the radical government-assistance programs of the New Deal that promoted the well-being of white families. Yet many white sociologists blamed unwed Black mothers for creating a dysfunctional family structure by displacing Black men as the heads of households and transmitting a depraved lifestyle to their children. â Nikole Hannah-Jones et al., The 1619 Project, 226
Categorization
- XREF: Moynihanâs report is a standard touchstone in sociology and policy studies; this passage matches the framing used in critiques like those in The Color of Law about deliberate exclusion from government programs.
- DEFINE: Shows the âpathology vs structureâ causal attribution the reader is tracking â distinguishing who was blamed versus what actually caused the outcomes.