Foucault wrote surveiller as an impersonal imperative with no true English equivalent.
Evidence
Any closer translation of the French title of this book, Surveiller et punir, has proved unsatisfactory on various counts. To begin with, Foucault uses the infinitive, which, as here, may have the effect of an āimpersonal imperativeā. Such a nuance is denied us in English. More seriously the verb āsurveillerā has no adequate English equivalent. Our noun āsurveillanceā has an altogether too restricted and technical use. Jeremy Bentham used the term āinspectā ā which Foucault translates as āsurveillerā ā but the range of connotations does not correspond. āSuperviseā is perhaps closest of all, but again the word has different associations. āObserveā is rather too neutral, though Foucault is aware of the aggression involved in any one-sided observation. In the end Foucault himself suggested Discipline and Punish, which relates closely to the bookās structure. ā Michel Foucault, Discipline & Punish- The Birth of theā¦, 14
Categorization
- XREF: Directly supports the readerās project of bridging Benthamās āinspectā to Foucaultās āsurveillerā and then to Orwellās telescreens.