Euphemistic acronyms like PAPs obscure forced displacementâs violence.
Evidence
The official terminology favored by the World Bank (for decades the core backer of megadams in the global South) is PAPsâProjected-Affected People. This bloodless, technocratic, deviously neutral term obscures the fact that those affected are inevitably negatively affectedâoften doomedâby the project in question. âProject affectedâ translates as involuntary eviction, loss of land, community dispersal, and plummeting life prospects. To cut through the pseudoneutrality of such bureaucratic jargon, big dam opponents have preferred a more direct language that underscores the violence involved, advancing terms that range from âousteesâ (an Indian neologism that has since garnered international currency) to Scudderâs âdevelopmental refugees.â â Rob Nixon, Slow Violence and the EnvironmentalismâŠ, 455
Categorization
- DEFINE: Defines PAPs, oustees, and developmental refugeesâterms this chapterâs whole argument turns on.
- XREF: Builds on ch1âs rhetorical unmasking of euphemism and ch8âs point that corporations manufacture doubtâhere the state/bank jargon plays the same masking role. â connects to: State violence is laundered through euphemisms that mask its banned nature â Albert Bandura, Moral Disengagement: How People Do HarmâŠ, 2148; Technocratic military jargon euphemistically erases civilian bodies from weaponsâ names â Rob Nixon, Slow Violence and the EnvironmentalismâŠ, 669; Bureaucratic-juridical vocabulary itself euphemizes the violence of drone strikes. â GreÌgoire Chamayou, A Theory of the Drone, 491
Broader Connections
- Bureaucratic-juridical vocabulary itself euphemizes the violence of drone strikes.
#exemplifies(0.90) â GreÌgoire Chamayou, A Theory of the Drone, 491 - State violence is laundered through euphemisms that mask its banned nature
#expands(0.85) â Albert Bandura, Moral Disengagement, 2148 - Technocratic military jargon euphemistically erases civilian bodies from weaponsâ names
#exemplifies(0.85) â Rob Nixon, Slow Violence and the EnvironmentalismâŠ, 669