Christian polemicists claimed Arabic science was stolen from Latin sources
Evidence
After glorifying Isidoreās piety and learning, Lucas explains that his successor, a shifty Greek named Teodistus, āa wolf in sheepās clothing,ā stole several manuscripts of Isidoreās as-yet-unknown works in medicine and other sciences, then āout of hatred of the Faith, excising the truth and inserting errors, had them translated from Latin into Arabic by a certain Arab named Avicenna,ā who pretended the works were his own. ⦠Faced with the impressive ediļ¬ce of Arabic science, Lucas responds that the Arabs stole it all from the good Isidore. ā John V. Tolan, Saracens, 940
Categorization
- XREF: An early textual ancestor of the modern trope that Islamic/Arab civilization contributed nothing original but merely copied the West ā grounds an existing vault claim about cultural-appropriation narratives.
- SEED: Essay angle: the medieval invention of Avicenna as plagiarist of Isidore as the deep ancestor of modern claims that Islamic science merely transmitted Greek knowledge.