Capitalism is the first thing-in-itself grounding all later metaphysical dilemmas.
Evidence
Yet this static relationship to the objects of knowledge is itself but a reflection of the life experience of the middle classes in the economic and social realm. Their relationship to the objects that they produce, to the commodities, the factories, the very structure of capitalism itself is a contemplative one, in that they are not aware of capitalism as a historical phenomenon, as being itself the result of historical forces, as having within itself also the possibility of change or of radical transformation. They can understand everything about their social environment (its elements, its functioning, its implicit laws) except the sheer historical existence of that environment itself: their rationalism can assimilate everything but the ultimate questions of purpose and origin. In this sense, capitalism is itself the first thing-in-itself, and the primal contradiction upon which all later, more specialized and abstract dilemmas are founded. ā Fredric Jameson, Marxism and Form, 378
Categorization
- DEEPTHINKING: The dialectical inversionācapitalism as the ur-noumenon, with Kantās thing-in-itself as derivativeāis the single most powerful move in this section and a paradigm-shifting way to read the history of philosophy.
- XREF: Directly the LukĆ”csian seed that Jameson cultivates into postmodernismās flattening of historicity; also echoes Marxās ācapital as an automatic subjectā and anticipates Žižekās capitalism-as-real.
- SEED: An essay angle: āCapital as noumenonāāreading the contemporary inability to imagine alternatives to capitalism as the latest form of the thing-in-itself dilemma, updated via Jameson to the postmodern.